This one’s hot off the presses. Just yesterday, our friends at the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) issued a press release on its latest ruling related to foreign ‘money service businesses (MSBs).’
An MSB is a private company that provides certain financial services like check cashing, money orders, title pawn, payday loans, travelers’ checks, prepaid stored value cards, tax refund payments, etc.
Frequently, traditional MSB clients tended to be individuals without bank accounts or access to credit. But increasingly, the US government is looking at companies engaged in electronic payments, crowdsourced funding, and even microcredit finance as money service businesses.
The implication? They should all be regulated. Even if they’re not even US companies.
That’s right. FinCEN’s latest ruling suggests a foreign MSB may now be subject to US regulations AND CRIMINAL PENALTIES “even if none of its agents, agencies, branches or offices are physically located in the United States.”
FinCEN goes on to say that foreign-located MSBs must also comply with US anti-money laundering regulations and submit ‘suspicious activity reports’, i.e. assimilate into the US financial system and become yet another unpaid spy of the US government.
Further, foreign MSBs must register with FinCEN AND appoint a person residing in the United States as a legal representative in matters of compliance. If not, foreign MSBs risk severe civil and criminal penalties.
Needless to say, FinCEN came up with this ‘rule’ all on its own. There was no legislative process, no Congressional debate. Quite simply, a bunch of bureaucrats decided to create a new rule that, amazingly enough, has the same weight and gravitas as a law.
This is the way society is ordered today. There’s one set of rules that Congress creates– the laws. Then there’s another set of rules that the President creates in his sole discretion– executive orders and the occasional treaty. Then there’s a third set of rules that are created by enforcement agencies like FinCEN– regulations and policies.
This is the part that’s truly extraordinary. Despite the ‘free and democratic society’ that most of us live in, these agencies are accountable to no one. They are not elected officials, they have no checks and balances, and there is little (if any) judicial oversight.
From the FBI’s “administrative subpoenas” that gives the agency nearly totalitarian authority to commandeer the information of private companies, to the Justice Department’s “policies” on civil asset forfeiture, to FinCEN’s “rules” subjecting foreign companies to US criminal penalties, this is getting completely out of control.
With nearly 100% certainty, as you read this sentence right now, you are in violation of probably several such rules and regulations that you’ve never heard of. Even if you’re not in the United States, as the FinCEN case clearly demonstrates.
Each of these rules has been conjured without your knowledge, put into effect without your consent, and tied to the most ridiculous civil and criminal penalties imaginable. You can’t even fill out a passport application anymore without being threatened with a $10,000 fine.
In his comprehensive annals of the reigns of Tiberius and Nero, Roman historian Tacitus wrote, “corruptissima re publica plurimae leges.” This is most often mistranslated as “the more corrupt a society, the more numerous its laws.”
In truth, Tacitus was referring to Rome’s history, and a more accurate translation is “laws were most numerous when the commonwealth was most corrupt.”
Future historians will likely look back and say the same thing about our society. Except that we’re not talking about laws. We’re talking about the ‘rules’ of autonomous enforcement agencies that have extensive (and growing) police powers.
A better quote comes from a 1969 speech from William T. Gossett, then president of the American Bar Association:
“The rule of law can be wiped out in one misguided, however well-intentioned generation. And if that should happen, it could take a century of striving and ordeal to restore it, and then only at the cost of the lives of many good men and women.”